Two Attendees of the First Thanksgiving: Separating Fact from Fiction
The "First Thanksgiving" is a cherished American holiday, steeped in tradition and often romanticized. However, the historical record surrounding the event is surprisingly sparse, making it difficult to definitively name specific attendees. What we know is based on fragmented accounts and interpretations of historical sources. Therefore, pinpointing individuals present is problematic. There's no surviving guest list!
Instead of naming two specific individuals with certainty, let's explore the likely participants and address common misconceptions.
Who Were the Likely Attendees?
It's more accurate to talk about groups of people rather than individuals. The event we celebrate as Thanksgiving was likely a harvest festival shared between the Pilgrims of Plymouth Colony and members of the Wampanoag tribe.
-
The Pilgrims: While we don't have a list of every Pilgrim present, we know the leadership would have been there. This would include figures like Governor William Bradford and Captain Myles Standish. They were central figures in the Plymouth Colony and highly likely participants in any significant gathering.
-
The Wampanoag: Identifying specific Wampanoag individuals is even more difficult due to the limited written records from their perspective. We know Massasoit, the Sachem (chief) of the Wampanoag, was a key figure and likely attended with a significant number of his people. However, specific names beyond Massasoit are lost to history.
Why Is It Hard to Name Specific Individuals?
Several factors contribute to the difficulty of naming specific attendees beyond the few leaders mentioned above:
-
Limited Documentation: The Pilgrims kept records, but these were primarily focused on the colony's governance and survival, not social events. Wampanoag accounts are mostly absent from written European records.
-
Cultural Differences in Record-Keeping: The Wampanoag had oral traditions rather than written ones, making it difficult to reconstruct the event from their perspective.
-
The Nature of the Gathering: The "First Thanksgiving" likely wasn't a formal, single event but a series of autumnal harvest celebrations that stretched over several days. This makes identifying precise attendees even more challenging.
What About Specific Names Often Mentioned in Popular Accounts?
Many popular accounts name individuals, but these are often based on interpretations and extrapolations from limited evidence. While some names might be plausible, assigning them definitively to the "First Thanksgiving" isn't historically accurate.
In Conclusion:
While it's tempting to name two specific people who attended the "First Thanksgiving," the historical evidence doesn't allow for that level of certainty. Focusing on the groups involved – the Pilgrims of Plymouth and the Wampanoag – offers a more accurate and respectful representation of this historically complex event.
